The Sound of Identity

Director: James Kicklighter
Release Year: 2020

"The Sound of Identity" (2020), directed by James Kicklighter, is a remarkable documentary that explores the journey of Lucia Lucas, an internationally acclaimed opera singer, who became the first openly transgender woman to perform a leading role in a major opera production. The film sheds light on her historic portrayal of Don Giovanni in the Tulsa Opera's production of Mozart's iconic opera, a groundbreaking moment in the world of opera.

 

While the film touches on the significance of Lucia's transgender identity, it is not defined solely by her transness. Instead, it delves into the universal themes of artistic pursuit, personal identity, relationships, and the power of resilience. Lucia Lucas is an inspiring figure, and though being transgender plays a role in her story, it is not the central focus of the documentary. This decision to not place her gender identity at the forefront allows viewers to engage with the more profound aspects of her artistic journey. It is the artistry, dedication, and courage of Lucia that stands out, making her portrayal of Don Giovanni not just a personal milestone but an artistic triumph. Her identity as a transgender woman is part of who she is, but it is her character, talent, and commitment to her craft that truly define her. Opera, a timeless art form that has been experiencing a decline in popularity over recent decades, provides the backdrop for this documentary. For the passionate few who continue to hold opera close to their hearts, the commitment and devotion to the art form are clear. 

 

The film provides a behind-the-scenes glimpse into the rigorous and often grueling world of modern opera. The long hours, the technological frustrations, the sacrifices made in the name of perfection, and the constant pressure to remain relevant in the world of live productions are all captured with empathy and insight. What makes "The Sound of Identity" truly special is its ability to humanize its subject. The film invites viewers into the world of opera and exposes the emotional and personal struggles that accompany the pursuit of artistic excellence. Through Lucia's eyes, we are reminded of the importance of adaptation and the necessity of staying true to one's passion, all while navigating the complexities of identity. The film is not just about the triumph of an individual artist; it is a tribute to the collective effort, the collaborations, and the bonds that are forged in the artistic process. One of the most captivating aspects of "The Sound of Identity" is the relationship between Lucia Lucas and her mentor, the renowned composer Tobias Picker. As the artistic director of the Tulsa Opera, Picker plays a pivotal role in Lucia's journey, and the bond between the two of them is central to the film’s emotional depth. Their dynamic evolves over the course of the documentary, revealing the challenges, inspiration, and mutual respect that underpin their relationship. Tobias Picker, an accomplished and respected figure in the world of opera, has risked his legacy by choosing Lucia for the role of Don Giovanni, a decision that resonates with both professional and personal significance. 

 

The documentary captures the intimate moments between the two, showcasing their conversations, their shared vulnerability, and the quiet moments of support that speak volumes. As Lucia opens up about her past and the personal hurdles she has faced, including the trauma of her parents' divorce and the complex journey of her transition, we see a deep emotional bond forming between them. Picker serves not only as a mentor but also as a father figure to Lucia, and their heartfelt exchanges serve as some of the most poignant moments in the film. The structure of "The Sound of Identity" is built around the tension leading up to the opening night of the Tulsa Opera's production of Don Giovanni. The documentary captures the intense pressure and uncertainty that come with such a high-stakes performance. Lucia is not only grappling with the typical challenges of preparing for a major role but also with the added layer of being the first transgender woman to headline a principal opera role in history. The ticking clock adds a sense of urgency to the narrative, amplifying the stakes and drawing viewers into the suspense of whether Lucia’s performance will be a success. At the same time, the documentary explores the difficulties of producing opera in modern times. Ticket sales are struggling, and Lucia questions whether her groundbreaking performance might be affecting the box office. 

 

The film addresses the reality of opera as a niche, expensive art form that often lacks widespread support. While there is a sense of insecurity and doubt, especially in the context of the conservative environment of Oklahoma, the support from Lucia's colleagues and mentors provides a source of strength. The film never allows the narrative to fall into a political or didactic stance; instead, it focuses on the personal and professional journey that Lucia undertakes as she challenges societal expectations and navigates her own insecurities. One of the core themes of "The Sound of Identity" is the exploration of identity in its many forms. While the documentary follows Lucia's transition, it is not a film about the specifics of gender identity or the politics surrounding transgender issues. Instead, it highlights the broader concept of identity, both personal and professional. Lucia is not defined by her gender transition; she is an artist, a performer, and a person navigating the complexities of self-discovery, growth, and acceptance. This is a refreshing departure from the typical narratives that focus heavily on the struggle or trauma associated with transitioning. Instead, the film offers a balanced perspective that showcases Lucia as a multifaceted individual. 

 

The documentary also delves into the intersection of identity and art, illustrating how our personal histories shape our professional journeys. For Lucia, her identity is inextricably linked to her art, and her voice, both literally and metaphorically, becomes a medium through which she expresses herself. The way the film tackles the theme of gender and voice in the context of opera is nuanced, allowing viewers to reflect on how identity can be a source of strength and resilience, especially in the face of societal expectations. For many, opera may seem like an antiquated art form, a world filled with grandiose productions, extravagant costumes, and a seemingly unreachable level of talent. "The Sound of Identity" seeks to demystify opera by providing a raw and honest look at the work that goes into bringing an opera production to life. It showcases the dedication, discipline, and passion required to succeed in this demanding field, but it also highlights the human side of opera - its struggles, vulnerabilities, and the emotional toll it takes on performers. In this sense, "The Sound of Identity" serves as a love letter to the art form, celebrating its beauty and power while acknowledging the challenges it faces in the modern world.

 

The documentary invites viewers to reconsider opera as a living, breathing art form that continues to evolve and adapt, just as the performers who grace its stages do. By focusing on Lucia’s performance and the collaborative nature of opera, the film reminds us of the transformative power of art to challenge norms, inspire change, and push boundaries. "The Sound of Identity" is more than just a documentary about the first transgender woman to perform in a leading opera role. It is a poignant exploration of what it means to live authentically, to pursue one's passion with unwavering dedication, and to navigate the complexities of identity in a world that is constantly changing. Through Lucia Lucas’ journey, the film speaks to anyone who has ever faced self-doubt, struggled with societal expectations, or sought to carve out a space for themselves in a world that doesn’t always understand them. Director James Kicklighter succeeds in creating a film that is both emotionally resonant and artistically compelling. The documentary is not just about the historical significance of Lucia's performance; it is about the universal journey of self-discovery, the pursuit of artistic excellence, and the power of human connection. "The Sound of Identity" offers an intimate, inspiring, and thought-provoking portrait of a remarkable artist and the transformative impact of art on identity.

 

via: youtube

 ameskicklighter.com and directorsnotes.com

Image credits: YouTube